What fish are in Nightmare Lake?

Nightmare Lake offers diverse fishing opportunities. Check with local fishing guides for current species information and fishing reports.

Where can I launch a boat on Nightmare Lake?

Check with local authorities or MT DNR for public access information for Nightmare Lake.

Do I need a fishing license to fish Nightmare Lake?

Yes, you need a valid MT fishing license to fish Nightmare Lake. Fishing licenses can be purchased online through the MT Department of Natural Resources (DNR) website or at local retailers. Non-residents may need to purchase a non-resident fishing license.

Can I hire a fishing guide for Nightmare Lake?

Yes! Find experienced local fishing guides and captains for Nightmare Lake on this page. Our professional fishing guides offer guided trips, provide all necessary equipment, and share expert knowledge of Nightmare Lake's best fishing spots and techniques.

How big is Nightmare Lake?

Nightmare Lake covers approximately 2.66 acres.

Montana fishing lakes map - Find top fishing spots

Nightmare Lake

City: Nye

County: Stillwater County

Nearest Town: Nye

Last updated: less than a minute ago

About Nightmare Lake

Surface Area3 acres

Plan Your Fishing Trip

Planning your fishing adventure at Nightmare Lake? Book everything you need for your trip to Nye with Booking.com's best price guarantee and free cancellation.

Hotels & Stays

From cozy lodges to lakeside resorts

Best price guarantee on 29M+ properties
Free cancellation on most rooms
Book now, pay at property

Flights

Get there faster, fish longer

Compare 100s of airlines instantly
Flexible dates & destinations
Save with exclusive flight deals

Car Rentals

Freedom to explore every spot

Compare all major rental companies
Free cancellation up to 48hrs
Reserve now, pay when you pick up

Powered byBooking.com

24/7 Customer Support

Fishing Charter Captains Near Nightmare Lake

Be the First Captain for Nightmare Lake

This prime fishing location is waiting for expert local guides like you. Start earning by sharing your knowledge of Nightmare Lake with anglers.

Why Join Fish Roulette•How Payments Work

More Fishing Lakes Near Nightmare Lake

Discover 6 nearby fishing spots within 50 miles. Find similar fish species, boat access, and local fishing guides for your next fishing adventure.

Sioux Charley Lake

City: Nye

County: Stillwater County

Near: Nye

32 acres

West Fishtail Creek Lakes

City: Fishtail

County: Stillwater County

Near: Fishtail

24 acres

Lake Wildness

City: Nye

County: Stillwater County

Near: Nye

23 acres

Cataract Lake

City: Nye

County: Stillwater County

Near: Nye

14 acres

Wood Lake

City: Nye

County: Stillwater County

Near: Nye

11 acres

Woodbine Lake

City: Nye

County: Stillwater County

Near: Nye

6 acres

Latest Fishing News & Updates

Stay informed with the latest fishing tips, stories, and updates from the community

Google Calendar Sync for Fishing Guides: Never Miss a Booking Again thumbnail

1/29/2026

Platform Updates

Google Calendar Sync for Fishing Guides: Never Miss a Booking Again

You can now hook up your Google calendar directly to your Fish Roulette calendar. That means no more juggling two different schedules or accidentally booking two trips at the same time.

Fishing Booking Settings: Hourly Pricing Model with Discount Tiers thumbnail

1/26/2026

Platform Updates

Fishing Booking Settings: Hourly Pricing Model with Discount Tiers

Before we added custom scheduling, pricing was straightforward. Captains set rates based on half-day blocks; morning or afternoon trips. Simple enough for everyone to understand. A half-day trip cost X amount, and customers could easily compare one captain to another.

Fine-Grained Scheduling Blocks: A Game-Changer for Fishing Charter Captains thumbnail

1/23/2026

Platform Updates

Fine-Grained Scheduling Blocks: A Game-Changer for Fishing Charter Captains

Running a fishing charter isn't just about knowing where the fish are biting. It's also about managing your time, your boat, and your bookings in a way that makes sense for your business. That's exactly why we built our newest feature at Fish Roulette; and it came directly from listening to captains like you.

Exclusive Access

Never Miss the Bite at Nightmare Lake

We're working diligently to bring you the best fishing experience. Stay tuned for more updates to come!

Lake Location

Loading contours...